By Anais Wheeler, Wcities Boston Contributor
Somewhere around mid-March, northeasterners go into winter denial. We shed layer after layer of clothing despite the fact that the temperature has flat-lined at late February levels. Counter-intuitive as it may be, this dependable phenomenon makes spring a prime hot drink season. By all means, wear your ultra-mini with your thick socks and Uggs (the inherent problems of this outfit I’ll leave to a more patient blogger), but when you find yourself shivering in the decidedly un-summer-like sun, don’t pop into a bar for a lime rickey; instead, cozy up with the ultimate in winter warmers, the hot toddy.
There is something endearing and comforting about the words “hot toddy.” This is a drink that your grandfather (and your grandmother!) loves, that might be carried around the neck of a St. Bernard, that emulates maternal remedies and a certain masculine sophistication. It is also a great measure of the character of a bar because the drink has so many variations. A quality hot toddy depends on the presence of a few quality ingredients—in my humble opinion, the basics are whiskey, honey, lemon and cloves, although tea is a nice touch—and the care with which it is made.
The hot toddy, sometimes called a hot whisky, is thought to be as Scottish in origin as it sounds, but the etymology of the word toddy is uncertain. Toddy may come from the Hindi word, tari (that ‘r’ is an alveolar tap; that is, it sounds like a quick ‘d’) for the juice of certain palm trees, which by extension also referred to the fermented wine made from this palm juice. Another possibility says toddy is a homegrown Scottish word, evidenced by an 18th century poem referring to “some kettles full of Todian spring;” that is, water from Tod’s well, which supplied Edinburgh’s water at that time. The logic goes that since whiskey comes from the Gaelic word for water, toddy was another tongue-in-cheek reference to something a bit stronger than that life-giving substance.
Of course, the origins of any drink matter little while you’re imbibing, and imbibe you shall, since I’ve discovered some of the best and worst hot toddies in the area.
A favorite JP haunt is the Alchemist, whose Hot Toddy is featured on the Winter Warmer section of the drink menu. The menu claims it is served with a cinnamon stick, but I’ve often gotten cloves, which are the more standard toddy brown spice anyway. The Alchemist’s hot toddy is just right, hot and served in a jiffy compared to the production that goes with serving this drink in certain other bars. Their menu also features another old classic, the Hot Buttered Rum, a deliciously caloric take on the hot alcoholic drink.
The South End’s Beehive is popular with those in the know and I’ve often heard touted the talent of the bartenders, and yet when I ordered the most stodgy and basic of warm drinks there, I got a tiny lukewarm mug about 10 minutes later. With the slightly jazz age slant of their cocktail menu, I expected more when I ordered a retro whiskey drink.
Wally’s Café was equally as unprepared for serving this hot drink, but their presentation was endearing. As a slightly dive-y, definitely boho, jazz destination, Wally’s bag is less the perfection of its cocktails and more the atmosphere and history of the joint. Thus, when the aging bartender took several minutes to carefully serve me lemon, honey and a shot of whiskey and then insisted that I put on my own gloves to transport the accompanying glass of hot tea to my table, I just kept tapping my foot to the hypnotic mid-afternoon jazz. The tea is a nice touch that few bars add, and at Wally’s it comes with guaranteed live music—365 days a year.
At the Joshua Tree in Somerville’s Davis Square, the hot toddy depends entirely on the bartender. One night, it featured an unidentifiable hot juice—still not sure if it had a little cider or if the sweet stuff was a bit of lemonade—with whiskey, honey, cloves and lemon. That special ingredient was nowhere to be seen a few weeks later, however, when the hot toddy was three parts honey to one part everything else. You might want to ask what you’ll be getting prior to ordering our subjective drink at this neighborhood standard.
The beauty of the hot toddy is that you can order it at almost any bar outside of the grungiest of dives (both the JP and the Financial District locations of J.J. Foley’s are unable to provide hot water, for example) and get a drink that says something about the service and attitude of that bar. It’s a drink that can catch a staff off-guard and demonstrate their knowledge or lack-thereof, and it will keep you warm in that misleading sunshine to boot!




Recent Comments